The latest Border-Gavaskar Trophy 2024-25 has created a lot of controversy regarding the way Indian players are playing, in particular Shubman Gill. Hailed as the next big thing in Indian cricket, Gill's recent exit has raised eyebrows, with critics questioning his place in the team. The former Indian cricketer also spoke out about his performance, labeling Gill as “excessive” and criticizing the selection committee for overlooking other relevant talents.
Shubman Gill's disappointment in Australia
In the Border-Gavaskar Trophy, Gill's batting was not impressive. He scored 31, 28, 1, 20, and 13 through five innings, which is very different from what was expected of a player of his caliber. Although the main focus has been on veterans like Virat Kohli and Rohit SharmaGill's failure to provide more information did not advance. His average of less than 30 overseas shows what happens to a player who was once considered a great player.
Also READ: “Telling players like Rohit or Kohli…”: Yograj Singh emphasizes on good team management
This myth supports the call for change
Krishnamachari SrikkanthComments on his YouTube channel have sparked discussions about bias in the selection committee. He said that when Gill continues to receive opportunities despite his poor performance, the players like it Suryakumar Yadav, Ruturaj Gaikwadand Sai Sudharsan they have been overlooked despite their impressive record in domestic cricket. Srikkanth insisted that new talent should be promoted instead of hanging around with players who fail to deliver consistently.
“I have always said that Shubman Gill is a great cricketer but no one listens to me. He is a highly touted cricketer. When Gill takes such a long rope… Srikanth said.
The story of other talents
The argument for promoting other players is compelling. Gaikwad has been very successful in top level cricket, while Sudharsan has made waves on the 'A' tour. Their inconsistent performances have led to questions about why they are not considered for the national team as players like Gill continue to struggle.
Srikkanth's determination that “Gill has survived because he gets ten chances and scores on the tenth chance” resonates with many fans who feel that meritocracy should lead to good decisions rather than history or bias.
Like India go through a phase of change in cricket, accountability in the selection committee becomes very important. Current players should be evaluated based on their performance, especially in situations like this Australia. The decision-makers must realize that while capability is important, consistency is essential for global success.
Ricky PontingGill's observations are also consistent with this view. He also said that Gill needs to trust his instincts and avoid overthinking his approach, which could cause him to struggle.